Alias Smith and Jones Writers

A forum devoted to writers of Alias Smith and Jones Fan Fiction
HomePortalGalleryFAQSearchRegisterLog in

Share | 

 Return to Devil's Hole

Go down 

PostSubject: Return to Devil's Hole   Mon Nov 26, 2012 10:11 am

In "Return to Devil's Hole," Clara Phillips tells Heyes she found him through Lom. This has always seemed an anomaly and out of sorts for Lom as a character, since he's the one who said, "It'll be our secret -- just you, me, and the Governor." As well, one would think a lawman would not want it known he has any dealings at all with wanted men, even if at least some might know he once rode with them.

Given this, do you think Lom really told her where to find the boys, or did she employ other means to find out? If the latter, how would she have known how and where to find them, or even to mention Lom's name?
Back to top Go down


Posts : 728
Join date : 2012-04-22
Age : 99
Location : The Comfy Chair

PostSubject: Re: Return to Devil's Hole   Tue Nov 27, 2012 7:11 pm

I've wondered about this, too. Of course, that means I'm taking her comment seriously, and not thinking of it as an example of some very convenient plot device from a less than adequate episode.

I think the whole arc of Clara's various stories about why she needed to go to Devil's Hole show that she was an accomplished liar. She also lied quite convincingly to the hotel clerk when she told him that Joshua Smith was her "dear brother" and that she'd travelled a long way to find him. Given that Clara can lie so easily and so comfortably, maybe she went to see Lom and told him a convincing lie. If Lom really believed that she was some damsel in distress, and was too rich to care for any bounty, maybe he thought it was a reasonable risk to direct her to Heyes. Even as I type this, though, I wonder why Lom wouldn't have contacted Heyes by some method to say, hey, I told this Phillips woman to find you, and that you could help her; I think she's okay.

How would she know about Lom? Well, we don't really know much about Lom's background except that he was with the Devil's Hole Gang at some point, and he later went straight. In the pilot episode, Heyes wants Lom to represent him and Curry to the governor, because Heyes think the governor knows by Lom's example than an outlaw can turn good, and mean it. What it Lom is well-known as the outlaw who turned good? Who knows, maybe there was even a dime novel about Lom's wilder days and his change of heart. He could be famous. If Lom's story was common knowledge only among lawmen and Bannerman, then the Bannerman agency, or some other private detective, might have suggested she contact him. He is a public official, so he's not hard to find.

As far as a lawman dealing with wanted men - well, it seems like lawmen have always had one or two informants among the shadier side of society. Even if Lom wasn't seeing Heyes and Curry regularly, he could very likely have contacts on the wrong side of the law. Had he wanted to get a message to Heyes or Curry, he probably could have done it. In the pilot episode, when Lom realizes Heyes is in his office, Lom pulls his gun and tries to arrest Heyes. That's not the reaction of someone who's been hanging around with his old outlaw friends on a regular, friendly basis!

Finally, did Clara ever mention anything about the amnesty deal? To my knowledge, it never came up. She wanted to find Heyes because he knew more about Devil's Hole than anyone and could be convinced to take her there. As far as I remember, Heyes discussed the amnesty with Big Jim and no one else. I don't believe the amnesty deal had any impact on Clara's decision to seek Heyes out.

After thinking about all this, I wonder why Clara wasn't looking for Heyes and Curry, or just Curry. Why did she focus so much on Heyes? The only way that makes sense to me is if Ben Murphy had the flu that week, so he was written out of the script.

OK, I'm going to bed now. Maybe. Sleep

"If it's worth doing, it's worth doing badly."

"The failure in doing something is stopping too soon."
Back to top Go down


Posts : 806
Join date : 2012-04-22
Age : 62
Location : Colorado

PostSubject: Re: Return to Devil's Hole   Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:49 am

I can't see Lom as someone who would fall for a sob story and reveal the boy's whereabouts either and always filled in that hole by telling myself that she was a wealthy woman so maybe she had used detectives who picked up the scent of the amnesty deal and worked back to the governor's office. Perhaps she found out the details of the amnesty deal and Lom's existence from the inside and used Lom's name because she knew he was a trusted friend. That could explain why she felt comfortable hiring a famous outlaw to guide her and also why she had to traipse around looking for Heyes. The governor would be unlikely to know where they were at any given moment.

This whole episode was so contrived. I couldn't see Heyes just wandering off with Clara's man to meet a stranger, even a pretty stranger, without him at least letting Kid know what was up. Kid was there in town, so why would Heyes just wander off without having Kid there to back him up. It doesn't seem like the actions of a man who had been on the run successfully for so long. It seemed unlikely that he would just leave Kid behind, too. I mean why not just make Clara what until they'd met with the Colonel?

One thing that always strikes me in this episode is the ending. Big Jim acts as though he doesn't even know Kid. That made me think that Kid came after Jim left, but still, he has to know who Kid is and, if he's such a good friend of Heyes, you'd think he'd be friendlier towards Kid.
Back to top Go down
Sponsored content

PostSubject: Re: Return to Devil's Hole   

Back to top Go down
Return to Devil's Hole
Back to top 
Page 1 of 1

Permissions in this forum:You cannot reply to topics in this forum
Alias Smith and Jones Writers  :: The Discussion Spot :: Banterings-
Jump to: